Only Murders in the Building Season 3, Episode 5: The Tell

Synopsis

The fifth episode of "Only Murders in the Building" season 3, titled "The Tell," aired on Hulu on December 14, 2023. In this episode, the trio continues to investigate the murder of Bunny Folger while balancing their personal lives.

The Investigation

Mabel is haunted by dreams about Bunny's murder and seeks therapy to cope with her trauma. Oliver and Charles are struggling to write their podcast, as they are unsure how to proceed with the investigation and respect Bunny's memory.

The trio decides to visit Bunny's apartment and search for clues. They discover a hidden diary in which Bunny reveals that she had a secret affair with Howard Morris, the father of Becky Butler. This revelation shocks the trio and leads them to suspect Howard.

Personal Struggles

Mabel is having trouble adjusting to her new life in the Arconia. She is struggling to find her place in the building and is feeling isolated. Oliver is dealing with the aftermath of his breakup with Teddy Dimas and is trying to find a new purpose in life.

Charles is caught in a love triangle between Jan Bellows and Lucy. He is torn between his feelings for both women and is unsure who he should pursue.

The Tell

The trio continues to investigate Howard and discovers that he has a history of violence. They also learn that he was seen arguing with Bunny the night she was murdered. The trio confronts Howard, who denies any involvement in Bunny's death but reveals that he has a "tell" whenever he is lying.

The trio tries to catch Howard in a lie by asking him a series of questions. However, Howard is able to control his "tell" and avoid giving any indication that he is lying.

Conclusion

The episode ends with the trio no closer to finding Bunny's killer. However, they have uncovered new information about Howard and his possible involvement in the murder. The trio is determined to continue their investigation and find justice for Bunny.